Beiträge: 5
| Zuletzt Online: 22.05.2013
-
-
I like you statement Timm, especial the end. I'm the same opinion. But there's somehing, we didn't considered now: Aristotelian three units! And like we all said before, this units are also against the idea of "Cal" as a Drama. Something like a unit of Time and place is not given in the book, maybe the unit of action, but for me, mostly not. In order to your statement, it shows, that "Cal" is to complex to be a drama, at least, for me, there are also to many persons acting, as it could be a drama.
Finaly, I think, we have thought of everything, so we could say, with a clear conscience, that "Cal" (never) can be a drama. There is no real Freytag pyramid, nor the Aristotelian three units and no tipical ending for a drama!
-
-
Thats a very nice question: I especial would like to answer your second question: Yes, they would kill even more for there point of view, then they did at the moment, because they would belive, that there task is given by god, like the crusades or the martyr belived (or still belive). If it would be more than a fight against the brits, a fight against a religion, there would be a adult (?) civil war. A killer would think, because he/she act's on behalf of god, no penalty will get from god but rather he/she will find reward in paradise.
-
-
I'm unsure as well. But i think you could call Cal's change ;) in relation to the IRA as a change in (his) conflict! Like our task in the exam, I think there's a change in his mind on page 57-58 and maybe a bit earlier. Before this passage he was just a follower to the leader, but from this passage on he begins to have his own opinion about the IRA and gets independet. In my opinoin you could say its a change in the conflicht and maybe even the climax?
-
First of all, thanks for this great question! I would partly agree with Berenike: Marcella maybe would go on loving Cal, because she no longer loved Robert, but i doesn't think, that the story would go on in the same, or nearly the same way, it does, rather Marcella would call the police. It may be not her first thought, that Cal himself would be arrested, but at least it was a terrible moment for her to see how the father of her children was shot down in her own house and thats why she want to see Crilly arrested by the police , so that Cal's arrest equals more a mistake, then she realy want it. Maybe the story would go on like this: Cal is prison and Marcella would visit him. Cal would be feel very guilty and please Marcella for forgiveness, but it will be unsure if Marcelle realy would forgive him.
-
|
|